Seeking Super Bowls, Not MVPs, Patrick Mahomes Is the Anti-Aaron Rodgers

Mahomes said winning a second MVP award "won’t matter" to him without a Super Bowl

Aaron Rodgers shakes hands with Patrick Mahomes after a preseason game.
Aaron Rodgers and Patrick Mahomes have different priorities.
Quinn Harris/Getty

The highest-paid player in the NFL thanks to a deal that was signed after he threw for 4,115 yards and 37 touchdowns last season and helped Green Bay lock up the NFC’s No. 1 seed, Aaron Rodgers entered this season hoping to win his third straight MVP award and fifth overall.

That is not going to happen, as the 39-year-old is not in the running for capturing an MVP award and barely has Green Bay in contention for a playoff spot in the NFC with a 5-8 record. Rodgers is probably upset about missing out on the postseason, but he may be even more disturbed about missing out on the chance of winning MVP for the fifth time, which would tie Peyton Manning for the most in league history.

Rodgers, who has previously complained about losing out on the 2012 MVP that was won by Adrian Peterson and was also miffed he “didn’t get a sniff” in the voting for the 2016 award, clearly cares about being recognized for his greatness. “There’s not many guys that have won three, so that would definitely mean a lot,” he said in 2020 about the prospect of winning a third MVP. “I think it should live up to what it stands for as an acronym. It’s that person who is most valuable to their team. I feel like that’s why I should be in the competition most years, and this year especially. It’s nice to be back in the conversation.”

Rodgers is out of that conversation (and will likely need some ayahuasca to help him process), but another former MVP winner who has as many Super Bowl wins as the longtime Packer quarterback (one) is squarely in it. The difference between Patrick Mahomes and Rodgers is that the Kansas City Chiefs star is far more concerned with winning Super Bowls than winning MVP awards.

“I honestly don’t care,” Mahomes told ProFootbalTalk after Sunday’s overtime win in Houston. “As long as we win the Super Bowl, it won’t matter to me. I just try to go out there and compete. I’ve won an MVP and I won a Super Bowl and a Super Bowl is a lot better.”

Going out on a limb, but it seems fairly likely that three-time MVP and seven-time Super Bowl winner Tom Brady would agree. Though no one is in his league, Brady seems far closer to Mahomes, who has played in two Super Bowls and won one since winning his first MVP, than Rodgers, who has never been back to the Super Bowl since winning his first MVP and has lost four times in the NFC Championship Game.

Win the Ultimate Formula 1® Miami Grand Prix Experience

Want the F1 experience of a lifetime? Here’s your chance to win tickets to see Turn 18 Grandstand, one of Ultimate Formula 1® Miami Grand Prix’s most premier grandstands!