Report: Luxury Wine Shop Owes Customers $1M Worth of Bottles

Controversy surrounds Sherry-Lehmann Wine and Spirits

Wine tasting
A 2005 tasting at Sherry-Lehmann Wine and Spirits.
Mario Tama/Getty Images

Whether a singular shop or a location of a chain, it’s sad news when a retailer closes its doors — for workers and customers alike. Late in 2022 and earlier in 2023, reports suggested that the prognosis for the long-running New York City wine shop Sherry-Lehmann Wine and Spirits was not great — with, among other things, a sizable unpaid tax bill cited as one of the reasons for its likely shuttering.

As per a New York Times article by James B. Stewart, the shop has indeed closed its doors, though its owners maintain that a comeback will take place shortly. But it turns out the tax bill is only part of what it might end up owing — as per Stewart’s report, the shop also accepted over $1 million in advance payments for bottles of wine it never delivered.

Stewart’s article cites “internal records reviewed by The New York Times and interviews with customers and former employees” — and, in one more wrinkle to the case, one of the affected customers is Stewart himself.

“[L]ast spring, I paid about $400 for a case of white Burgundy, which was supposedly in stock,” he wrote. “I never received the wine, and the company refused to issue a refund or credit, saying the wine was on back order and would arrive soon.” Soon enough, the shop had stopped returning his calls.

Vintage Bourbon Shops Raided by Kentucky State Agency
It’s a high-profile raid in the vintage whiskey community

The article goes on to point to Sherry-Lehmann’s policy of selling “wine futures” — essentially, payments for as-yet-unreleased vintages made a few years in the future — as another way that the shop wound up absorbing more of its customers’ money.

Whether you’re selling high-end wine to an affluent clientele or something much more modest, one rule of thumb generally applies to retailing: a transaction only works if both parties hold up their part of the deal. If a customer pays without getting anything in return, that’s a problem; multiply that countless times, and you have something much worse.


Join America's Fastest Growing Spirits Newsletter THE SPILL. Unlock all the reviews, recipes and revelry — and get 15% off award-winning La Tierra de Acre Mezcal.