The Best New Whiskeys to Seek Out This November (Including Holiday Releases!)

First order of business: our favorites from Buffalo Trace’s 2021 Antique Collection. But also: roast turkey whiskey?

October 29, 2021 8:50 am
Buffalo Trace 2021 Antique Collection, which does not feature George T. Stagg
The four releases from Buffalo Trace's 2021 Antique Collection
Buffalo Trace

Welcome back to our monthly guide to all things whisk(e)y. This month: The limited-edition and holiday releases all seem to drop at once. Also? Whiskey gets a New England Thanksgiving makeover from one experimental distillery.

Sazerac Rye 18 Year-Old
Sazerac Rye 18 Year-Old
Buffalo Trace

Buffalo Trace 2021 Antique Collection

The fall release of the (BTAC) is an important annual event for whiskey lovers, featuring a sought-after assortment of uncut, unfiltered and heavily aged whiskies. This year? No George T. Stagg. The distillery noted that this year’s 15-year old Stagg “did not meet … taste standards for the Stagg brand.”

So, how’s the rest of the collection? We tried the William Larue Weller wheated bourbon, Thomas H. Handy Sazerac Rye, 100-proof Eagle Rare 17-Year-Old and 90-proof Sazerac 18-Year-Old, and all had their strengths (and these are strong). The Weller was nutty and spicy, while the Sazeracs brought in notes of anise, cinnamon, cocoa and coffee. 

New Belgium Oakspire Bourbon Barrel Ale
New Belgium Oakspire Bourbon Barrel Ale
New Belgium Brewing

New Belgium Oakspire Bourbon Barrel Ale

An annual release (since 2018), this New Belgium release utilizes a “custom-built, proprietary infusion method to pull the flavors from the bourbon-steeped charred oak and marries it with a malty-sweet, deep amber ale.” This year, that bourbon oak arrives courtesy of Four Roses. Overall, this is malt-forward, fruity and features notes of toffee, coconut and vanilla.

Bird of Courage
Bird of Courage
Tamworth Distillery

Bird of Courage

From Tamworth, the New Hampshire distillery that brought you a venison (and a beaver sac) whiskey, comes this seasonally appropriate, limited-edition, roasted turkey-flavored whiskey. It’s essentially a barrel of 5-year-old Bottled in Bond bourbon steeped with “mostly” historically accurate ingredients from a New England Thanksgiving dinner. And actually, the locally sourced flint corn, chestnuts, apples, cranberries, squash, parsley and sage will probably work just fine here (and hey, turkey is kinda flavorless).  

Redwood Empire Grizzly Beast
Redwood Empire Grizzly Beast
Redwood Empire

Redwood Empire Whiskey

Hailing from Sonoma County, each release from this California distillery is named after an iconic tree in the Redwood Empire region. Celebrating its 10th anniversary, the distillery just released its first two bottled-in-bond releases, the Rocket Top Straight Rye and a Grizzly Beast Straight Bourbon. The latter features some delicious fruity notes (raspberry, orange zest) along with the more expected nutty, caramel and brown sugar notes. 

The Macallan Harmony Collection Rich Cacao
The Macallan Harmony Collection Rich Cacao
The Macallan

The Macallan Harmony Collection Rich Cacao

A new limited-edition release from the nearly 200-year old Speyside distillery is both a sweet (literally!) collaboration with pastry chef Jordi Roca and master chocolatier Damian Allsop and a new line of limited-edition single malts that’ll emphasize the Macallan’s sustainable packaging initiative. To that end, the bottle arrives in a fully recyclable and biodegradable presentation box made using natural by-products in the chocolate-making process. As for the whisky? Here, they sought out the sherry-season oaks casks that offered chocolate notes, and they nailed it — this is a rich, indulgent cocoa delight.

Wild Turkey Master’s Keep One
Wild Turkey Master’s Keep One
Wild Turkey

Wild Turkey Master’s Keep One

The sixth limited-edition Master’s Keep offering from the famed Lawrenceburg, KY, distillery represents the two different styles of Master Distiller Eddie Russell and his distilling legend father Jimmy. Here, that means a mid-aged bourbon (8-10 years) — Jimmy’s choice — combined with a 14-year release (Eddie’s choice) that are mingled together in a second maturation in specially charred new oak barrels. 

Garrison Brothers 2021 Limited-Edition Cowboy Bourbon
Garrison Brothers 2021 Limited-Edition Cowboy Bourbon
Garrison Brothers

Garrison Brothers 2021 Limited-Edition Cowboy Bourbon

The crafters of Texas’s first legal bourbon  just launched this uncut, unfiltered, 131.3 proof release, which usually sells out its initial allotment in hours. Utilizing a sweet mash bill and exposed to the extreme high heat of Texas (they have to use custom barrels), this barrel-proof expression features notes of pipe tobacco, banana nut bread, chocolate and cherry. And at 131.3 proof, you’ll want to add a bit of water to cut the heat.

High West A Midwinter Night's Dram Act 9
High West A Midwinter Night’s Dram Act 9
High West

High West A Midwinter Night’s Dram Act 9

The ninth annual release from this Utah distillery features the distillery’s Rendezvous Rye finished in Ruby and Tawny Port barrels for an additional 1-2 years, adding in seasonally appropriate aromas and flavors like sugar plums, spiced orange peel, dark fig, cinnamon and toffee.

Booker’s Bourbon 2021-03 “Bardstown Batch"
Booker’s Bourbon 2021-03 “Bardstown Batch”
Booker’s

More news: A “non-fungible” barrel of 1991 Macallan Scotch set a whiskey auction by selling for $2.3 million on the NFT marketplace Metacask … The veteran-led Horse Soldier Bourbon broke ground on a new $200 million distillery experience on the Kentucky Bourbon Trail … Fireball now comes in kegs that contain 115 shots (!) … Booker’s just released “Bardstown Batch,” the third of its 2021 Collection, which as usual is uncut and unfiltered (more on this one soon) … El Tesoro, one of our favorite tequilas, just launched an añejo that spent time aging in Laphroaig barrels (full review coming soon).

MEET US AT YOUR INBOX. FIRST ROUND'S ON US.

Join America's Fastest Growing Spirits Newsletter THE SPILL. Unlock all the reviews, recipes and revelry — and get 15% off award-winning La Tierra de Acre Mezcal.