A Meat-Lover’s Guide to the Best Steaks in Town

6 choices for a decadent meal

August 10, 2017 9:00 am EDT

Sometimes, nothing will do but the absolute best cut of meat. 

Surrounded by couple Manhattans and a table full of sides. 

Below, our picks for the best steakhouse experiences in town.

Alexander’s Steakhouse
In brief: This is S.F. location of the Cupertino original — the latter of which once held two Michelin stars. Regardless: For super-luxe steak with a Cali-Japan perspective, it’s hard to do better
What we’re ordering: The custom tasting menu known as the Chef’s Table Experience — details depend on seasonal availabilities but rest assured “this menu will be yours to keep and will never be replicated.”
Surrounded by: Whatever’s on the tasting menu — but it’ll have the cross-cultural flair of something like the chilled foie gras from the Bites menu.
And from the bar: They’ll provide a pairing with the tasting menu — or just ask the somm for his pick. 

Alfred’s Steakhouse
In brief: Nearly 100-year-old steakhouse earns a deluxe revamp courtesy of Daniel Patterson — and soon after its grand reopening, a second chance for tweaks after a fire briefly knocked it out of commission. 
What we’re ordering: The 28-ounce Alfreds Cut (“California cattle, grass-fed, grain finished, then dry aged for succulent flavor”), with the whipped horseradish sauce
Surrounded by: Onion rings and grilled broccoli
And from the bar: The House Martini, with Gordon’s Gin, Noilly Extra Dry, orange bitters, and lemon oil

Epic Steak
In brief:
“Epic” can refer equally to the views over the Bay or the menu. Just get a seat as close to the windows as possible and you’re set. 
What we’re ordering: The Tomahawk rib-eye and lobster for two
Surrounded by: French fries in Bernaise sauce and roasted baby carrots in a dill cream 
And from the bar: For the next 60 days, the Eugenia Central Coast rosé 

Harris’ Restaurant
In brief: An ultra-classic steakhouse — think creamed spinach and porterhouse, rather than edamame and wagyu.
What we’re ordering:
The 16-ounce 49er cut of Harris’s dry-aged Midwestern beef, prepared by an in-house butcher. And possibly a side of the seared foie gras? 
Surrounded by: 
Maine lobster mac ‘n’ cheese and sautéed button mushrooms
And from the bar: 
A bottle of red from the vineyard where you took her on a date — plus $30 for the corkage fee

House of Prime Rib
In brief: 
An English-inflected steakhouse that’s serving as close as you’ll find stateside to a Sunday roast — with superior meat and a Yorkshire pudding worth coming back for
What we’re ordering: The English Cut, because sometimes a little bit less — this is a thinner cut — is quite a bit more
Surrounded by: From the array of dinner accompaniments, we’ll be trying the Yorkshire pudding (as noted) and the salad
And from the bar: How about a Cab Sauv from Neal Howell Mountain Estate?

5A5
In brief: A full-on Japanese steakhouses dedicated to its titular elements: the five senses (all of which, they claim, will be delighted by the dining experience, and wagyu A5 beef
What we’re ordering:
The A5 Experience, of course, with four ounches each of “wagyu ny, wagyu filet, wagyu ribeye, [and] wagyu ribcap”
Surrounded by: “Shrooms” (Japanese mushrooms in a sherry and garlic sauce) and mashed potatoes with smoked white cheddar cheese
And from the bar: 

Meet your guide

Diane Rommel

Diane Rommel

Diane Rommel has written for The Wall Street Journal, Outside, Marie Claire, Cosmopolitan, Travel + Leisure, Wallpaper and Afar, as well as The Cut, Buzzfeed, Huffington Post and McSweeney’s. She once drove from London to Mongolia, via Siberia.
More from Diane Rommel »

EMAIL IS THE NEW HAPPY HOUR

Every Thursday, our resident experts see to it that you’re up to date on the latest from the world of drinks. Trend reports, bottle reviews, cocktail recipes and more. Sign up for THE SPILL now.