NYC Fishmonger Joe Gurrera's Simple Ceviche Recipe

When it comes to selling seafood in New York City, Joe Gurrera is the Fisher King. The son of an Italian immigrant, Gurrera began honing his skills as a fishmonger as a teenager working with his father at the family’s shop in Greenwich Village. A quick study in the family business, he soon graduated to going to the Fulton Fish Market to source seafood and eventually went into business for himself after college, supplying customers on both coasts — including Wolfgang Puck — with fresh fish.

Then, in 1983, Gurrera purchased a small, stand-alone seafood shop called Citarella on Manhattan’s Upper West Side. With Gurrera steering the ship, that shop has now morphed into a string of markets offering seafood and other gourmet goods located throughout New York City, the Hamptons and in Greenwich, Connecticut.

One of the offerings at Citarella, which also has an online seafood store that ships nationwide, is ceviche, a classic Latin American dish Gurrera had for the first time in Mexico about 30 years ago and fell in love with thanks to its freshness and the combination of bright flavors and fresh seafood. Since then, it has become one of Gurrera’s go-to dishes for entertaining.

“The key component to making a great ceviche is to start with the highest quality, freshest ingredients,” he tells InsideHook. “You can create many different variations with seafood and vegetables, but the one ingredient you just can’t skip is fresh cilantro. That’s what infuses the dish with its signature unique flavor.”

During the summer, ceviche is a staple for Gurrera that he is constantly experimenting with — he says he typically enjoys it at least once a week.

“My advice for making a great ceviche: cut all of your seafood and ingredients uniformly,” he says. “Who wants to eat a big piece of onion? You want to enjoy the marriage of all the flavors in one bite, which means everything has to be the same size. Also, scoop the seeds from the tomatoes and remove excess liquid before chopping. Otherwise, the flavors aren’t balanced.”

Joe Gurrera, the owner and fishmonger of Citarella in New York City.

Below, you’ll find Gurrera’s six-step recipe for ceviche from his debut cookbook Joe Knows Fish: Taking the Intimidation Out of Cooking Seafood. And, for those who like it spicy and want to kick things up a notch, he has a suggestion: “Try doubling the amount of jalapeños in my recipe, and if you are really daring, triple it.”

Joe Gurrera’s Simple Ceviche

Ingredients

½ pound raw sea scallops cut into ½-inch pieces
½ pound raw large shrimp (16 to 20 per pound) peeled, deveined and cut into ½-inch pieces
½ pound skinless fluke or skinless striped bass fillet cut into ½-inch pieces
2 plum tomatoes seeded and pulp discarded, cut into ¼-inch dice (about ½ cup)
1 small yellow onion cut into ¼-inch dice
1 to 2 jalapeño peppers seeded and finely chopped
Sea salt to taste
½ cup roughly chopped cilantro leaves
1½ cups freshly squeezed lime juice (from about 10 limes) plus more as needed
2 ripe avocados peeled, pitted and sliced for garnish
White rice for serving (optional)

Instructions

In a large bowl, combine the scallops, shrimp, fluke, tomatoes, onion and jalapeños to taste and toss to combine.
Sprinkle with a few generous pinches of salt and the cilantro and toss again.
Pour the lime juice over the mixture, making sure the mixture is completely covered by the liquid.
Cover with plastic wrap and let sit at room temperature for at least one hour. (Once “cooked,” by the limes, the ceviche can keep for about three days refrigerated.)
Use a slotted spoon to serve as is or over white rice.
Garnish with avocado.